UPDATE 3-U.S. top court rules against Argentina in arbitration fight
By Lawrence Hurley
WASHINGTON, March 5 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday reinstated a $185.3 million arbitration award British company BG Group Plc won against Argentina before an appeals court threw it out.
On a 7-2 vote, the high court said the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., should not have thrown out the award. Argentina had argued the case should have been litigated in its courts first before it could go to arbitration.
The dispute concerned whether BG should recover the money on the grounds that a decision by the Argentine government during its 2001 economic crisis to freeze gas prices breached a 1993 treaty between Britain and Argentina. Both BG, via its lawyer, and Argentina declined to comment on the ruling.
In the majority opinion, Justice Stephen Breyer said a decision on whether the dispute was subject to arbitration was up to arbitrators.
"In our view, the matter is for the arbitrators, and courts must review their determinations with deference," he wrote.
Chief Justice John Roberts, joined by Justice Anthony Kennedy, wrote a dissenting opinion saying that the investment treaty called for disputes to go to arbitration only if both parties agreed to it.
The treaty was meant to encourage investment by foreign companies such as Reading, England-based BG. Argentina imposed the price freeze shortly after it announced in December 2001 a sovereign debt default of roughly $100 billion. Continuación...